Classical Music | Soprano

Franz Schubert

Nur wer die Sehnsucht kennt, from Mignon Lieder, D. 877  Play

Susanna Phillips Soprano
Lydia Brown Piano

Recorded on 10/06/2010, uploaded on 02/28/2011

Musician's or Publisher's Notes

Nur wer die Sehnsucht kennt ("Only one who knows longing") is one of three poems, set to music by Schubert, from Goethe's novel Wilhelm Meisters Lehrjahre ("Wilhelm Meister's Apprenticeship"). Already set multiple times by Beethoven and later by Schumann, Wolf and Tchaikovsky, Schubert himself composed six different versions of Goethe's poem. Two versions—a duet and a solo song—were composed in January 1826 and published as part of his 4 Gesänge aus 'Wilhelm Meister', op. 62 the following year.

 

No doubt, judging from its multiple settings by a few of the greatest representatives of classical music, Goethe's poem is overflowing with emotion and drama, begging to be expressed in tone. Schubert takes every opportunity to express the longing (Sehnsucht) of Goethe's words. The song opens with the piano sounding a varied form of what will be the vocal melody. Emotional tension is immediately felt, first, in the elision of the leading note from the opening measure emphasizing the somber tone; second, by a poignant D-sharp appoggiatura to the A minor harmony of the second measure; and, finally, the chromatic C-sharp and B-flat in the following measure—and all this just within three bars of music!

 

The first two lines of Goethe's text are treated as a single unit. These same lines, as well as the accompanying music, will be recapitulated later at the end of the song. The final four lines of the first stanza wander from the starting tonality of A minor into the remote key of C minor. However, in a brilliant stroke, Schubert returns to the tonic by means of a single chord to close the first stanza on a half cadence in A minor. The opening lines of the second stanza begin over a disturbing chord of the second on the subdominant. At the words "I feel dizzy," the music breaks off into a series of repeated chromatic harmonies hovering inconclusively between the keys of D minor, C minor and A minor. After finally settling on the dominant harmony of A minor, the opening lines and music are repeated. The piano introduction also returns, bringing an end to one of Schubert's most heartfelt Lieder.      Joseph DuBose